On a day marked by inclement weather and mounting frustrations, Jesús Luzardo took to the mound at Citizens Bank Park, buoyed by a sense of optimism. As Mobb Deep’s "Survival of the Fittest" echoed through the stadium, Luzardo’s confidence was palpable; he remarked that, compared to the past month and a half, "My arm felt like a whip." However, what followed was a performance that would become both historically significant and deeply disappointing for the Phillies and their fans.
The game saw a swift turn of events as Luzardo faced off against the Milwaukee Brewers. It began with a soft second-pitch single from Jackson Chourio, quickly followed by a stolen base and a walk. The chain reaction continued with a line drive from Christian Yelich that brought Chourio home, soon followed by a three-run homer that transformed beloved Phillies player Rhys Hoskins into an unexpected target of boos. Within mere moments, Luzardo found himself and his team trailing 4-0, with no outs in the first inning.
Luzardo reflected on the frustrating turn of events stating, "I felt as athletic as I have all year. I think that’s when I’m at my best: when I feel athletic, and that’s why it was frustrating, how it went today." Unfortunately for him, the situation worsened dramatically as the game progressed. In a calamitous fourth inning, Luzardo's four earned runs burgeoned into an astonishing twelve, resulting in the Phillies suffering a staggering 17-7 loss—marking their heaviest defeat of the season.
This train wreck of an outing not only ranks as Luzardo's worst performance over seven seasons but also goes down in Philadelphia's baseball history. The last time a Phillies pitcher allowed as many runs dates back to June 28, 1947, a time when most current fans were not yet born.
Luzardo entered the game as a reliable component in the Phillies’ rotation, posting solid statistics prior to this outing with 16 earned runs allowed and 77 strikeouts over 67 innings pitched, boasting an impressively low ERA of 2.15, which ballooned to 3.58 after this game. Despite a subpar performance in a recent outing against the Athletics, the expectation was that Luzardo would power through—his previous struggles often involved early hiccups followed by effective long-term innings.
However, Saturday was an entirely different story. Luzardo struggled with execution, which was further exacerbated by a balk call on a move he had routinely used throughout his career. This decision led to heated exchanges with umpires—a testament to Luzardo's frustration—as well as a necessary ejection of manager Rob Thomson for maintaining his protest.
His go-to pitch, a sweeper, turned out to be ineffective. Luzardo had previously achieved considerable success with it but faced a determined set of lefty hitters from Milwaukee. Realmuto suggested that the Brewers had simply capitalized on Luzardo's mistakes, while others noted that he failed to maintain control. An example of this was evident when an 86.9 mph sweeper drifted from his command to Sal Frelick, resulting in an outfield debacle where communication between outfielders Nick Castellanos and Brandon Marsh failed, leading to more hits.
Defensive errors compounded Luzardo's struggles, with one instance leading to an error that put additional pressure on the pitcher and the entire team. In this chaotic sequence, the scoreboard quickly illustrated the mounting deficit, with Luzardo being yanked after just one out in a grim fourth inning.
"The way he grinds, the way he battles and competes, you’re thinking he’s going to get out of it," Thomson remarked, emphasizing a deep-seated belief in Luzardo's potential. Yet Saturday's desolation was uncharacteristic and added to the ongoing uncertainty surrounding Luzardo, who had started the season strong after a series of injuries plagued his previous year.
Despite logging 70 1/3 innings on Saturday—more than he managed all through the previous year—both Luzardo and Thomson attributed his difficulties to fluctuating execution rather than workload. The former agreed that his velocity remained intact, a crucial factor for a pitcher’s success.
The implications of Luzardo’s unprecedented loss extended beyond just his individual performance, placing added strain on a bullpen already grappling with its challenges. Three relievers plus a position player were forced to step in amidst the chaos, surrendering a combined 11 hits across 5 2/3 innings. The Phillies now face a pressing question of how to navigate the remainder of the season while managing the fallout from José Alvarado's suspension due to PED use and Luzardo's unexpected decline.
Ultimately, while Luzardo displayed the spirit that could define a starter, the day ended as a testament to how unpredictable baseball can be. The matchup with Milwaukee served as a wake-up call for Luzardo and the entire team, underscoring the urgency to recalibrate in hopes of rebounding from an unforgettable loss in Philadelphia.
Bias Analysis
Key Questions About This Article
